![]() |
There is a difference in results between ICM SWMM and ICM SIM (InfoWorks networks) when a subcatchments’ internal routing set to ‘pervious’ is due to a difference in implementation/methodology. Hence a larger volumes of runoff In ICMSWMM than ICM SIM’s implementation as the pervious infiltration, using the recently added CNSWMM to the ICM SIM.
We request consider adding the ICM SWMM implementation to ICM SIM as a new feature.
Disclaimer: The development, release, and timing of any features or functionality described or discussed for our products in this User Feedback Forum for Autodesk Water Products and Services remains at our sole discretion. This User Feedback Forum for Autodesk Water Products and Services is not a commitment, promise, or legal obligation to deliver any functionality, is intended solely to outline and gather feedback about our general product direction, and should not be relied on in making purchasing decisions.
Thanks all for your feedback on modifying the ICM routing to match SWMM networks. Rather than adding a new option we have changed the behavior of ICM SIM to match SWMM. This is available in 2024.4 and above (note database update required!).
Thank you Bob for clarifying the ideas. We all would love to have the SWMM5 hydrology equipped in InfoWorks ICM (SIM) and the user will have sole choice implementing what suits the region and standard belong to achieve a success modeling and deliverable. Also that will adding more value to the Infoworks ICM.
An image of the two options discussed in the idea
There are two distinct routing methods described in this Idea:
Impervious to Pervious Internal Routing:
Rainfall hits an impervious surface, producing "runon."
This runon, combined with direct rainfall, impacts the pervious surface.
The pervious surface then produces "runoff" and allows some water to infiltrate the ground.
The runoff from the pervious surface contributes to the lateral inflow, which then proceeds to a node.
Direct Routing:
Both impervious and pervious surfaces receive direct rainfall.
Each surface produces its own runoff, with the pervious surface also allowing for infiltration.
The runoff from both surfaces combines to form the lateral inflow, which then leads to a node.
a little diagram to further explain this
Impervious to Pervious Internal Routing
Rainfall Rainfall + Runon
↓ ↓
------------------- -------------------
| Impervious | | Pervious |
| | | |
------------------- -------------------
↓ ↓ ↓
Runon Runoff Infiltration
↓
Lateral Inflow
↓
Node
Direct Routing
Rainfall Rainfall
↓ ↓
------------------- -------------------
| Impervious | | Pervious |
| | | |
------------------- -------------------
↓ ↓ ↓
Runoff Runoff Infiltration
↓ ↓
+--------------------+
↓
Lateral Inflow
↓
Node